Maine Antique Digest
Maine Antique Digest
Gallery Advertisers
Search Our Advertisers


Derek Poole.com

Limner's Cottage

Direct link to John R. Snedden Ltd.

Direct link to Twickenham Antiques

Books on Ruby Lane

Oh. - A Felicitous Gathering of Curious Goods

Northeast Auctions

Bruce Rigsby Antiques

Susan Golashovsky, ASA-Personal Property Appraiser

The Manhattan Arts & Antiques Center

The Antique Store in Wayne, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Adrian Morris Antiques

SeeAuctions.com

Antiques At 30B

Read The Current Issue

Faith Viland’s Antiques

Walpoles

Brian Cullity

One Good Eye

Direct link to Antique Associates at West Townsend

Antique Center of Strabane

UNCERTAIN TIMES DEMAND SMARTER MARKETING

AntiqueSpider.com

Latique, The Antique Resource for Dealers

The Sportsman's Eye, Decoys & Sporting Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

The Stanley Weiss Collection, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Richard Latour & Ann Keller-Millstone Antiques

Heart of Country Antiques Show

Gentle Giant Restoration & Conservation

Austin T. Miller American Antiques

John Keith Russell Antiques

Marion Harris - We Strive for a Perfect Sense of Balance

Antiques Associates at West Townsend

Direct link to Nancy Steinbock Vintage Posters

De Wolfe & Wood Rare Books

Sasha's Antiques

Direct link to Brasseur Fine Arts

Direct Link to Peter H. Eaton Antiques

Cherry Brook Woodworks

Down Home Antiques

MacKay and Field Antiques

Austin T. Miller

ISA Annual Conference

Direct Link to Hampshire Antiques Ltd.

Antiques Dealers' Association of America, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Postcards on Ruby Lane

Sheridan Loyd Antiques

Direct link to American Primitive Gallery

Raven’s Way Antiques

American Marine Model Gallery -- Ship Model Restorations & Appraisals

Merry Walk Antiques ~ Joan Datesman, The Quimper Specialist, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

The Royal Scot, Inc.

Gentle Giant, Restoration and Conservation, Antiques Trade Directory Advertisement

Fisher Heritage

Nutting House Antiques

M. Finkel & Daughter, Antique Sampler Web Site

The Tuckaseigee Trader

Christine Gardner Antiques

Late-Breaking News on Auctions, Art, and Antiques

Thurston Nichols American Antiques, LLC

Jordan Antiques

Blue Dog Antiques

Direct link to David Pool Antiques

Porcelain on Ruby Lane

Anne Frances Moore: Fine Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Patricia Stauble Antiques, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Leonards New England Antique Beds & Fine Antique Furniture Our Specialty Since 1933!

McClellan Elms Antiques

George Subkoff Antiques, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Glass on Ruby Lane

Woodbury Antiques Dealers Association

Joshua Lowenfels, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Clifford A. Wallach Tramp Art Gallery

Sow's Ear Antique Company

Ryder Antiques-Americana and International Folk Art and Painted Furniture

Vintage Clothing on Ruby Lane

Michael Hall Antiques, Southern Decorative Arts. "Iron Plaque, Petersburg, Virginia"

Jewelry on Ruby Lane

America's Pride Antiques

John Chaski Antiques

Barbara Ardizone Antiques

Marna Anderson

Direct link to Nantucket Country

Jewett-Berdan Antiques

Thomas R. Field Antiques

Griffiths Antiques

Linda Rosen Antiques

George Subkoff Antiques

Fred Giampietro Folk Art and Americana

Direct link to Southampton Antiques American Victorian Furniture

Jane F. Wargo-Country Painted Furniture, baskets, trade signs, hooked rugs

Direct link to Staneika Antiques

John C. Hill • Antique Indian Art

Jeff & Holly Noordsy

The Manhattan Art & Antiques Center

Baker & Co. Antiques

Direct link to Vancouver Architectural Antiques

DBR Antiques, Americana - Folk Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Dolls on Ruby Lane

Susan Heider Antiques

Home Farm Antiques, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Robert J. Riesberg

Kaller Historical Documents, Inc.

Fine Art on Ruby Lane

Direct link to David H. Horst Antiques

Classified Ads

American Antiques Inc.

Just Folk American Antique and Outsider Art

South Street Antiques Litchfield, CT

Authentic Designs - Early American Lighting Fixtures

Malleries International Antique & Luxury Goods Mall

The Barometer Shop ~ C. Neville Lewis, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

The Halliday House Antiques Barn

Stella Rubin

Charles L. Flint Antiques, Inc.

Prices 4 Antiques

Carlson & Stevenson

Showcase Antique Center

Samuel Herrup Antiques

Direct link to Lynn and Rob Morin Antiques, Americana and Folk Art

James Hastrich, Maker of American Painted Furniture in 1" and 2" scale

Bid at Online Auctions

Antiques by Design

Direct link to Jenkinstown Antiques

Direct link to John D. Wahl Antiques

Douglas Hamel Antiques www.shakerantiques.com

The Dongan Collection, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

USFolkArt.com - American Antiques

Antiques on Ruby Lane

Finney Folk Art

David Nassar Antiques

Kuttner American Antiques

Halsey Munson Americana

Charles Haver Antiques

Direct link to The Splendid Peasant Ltd,

Crocker Farm Stoneware & Redware Auction

Patriot Antique Shoppe

Don Olson Fine American Antiques

Claude and Sharon Baker Antiques

Keepers Antiques

Scott Landon Antiques & Old Canada Country Antiques

Scott Fraser Antiques

Dig Antiques

Jeffrey Tillou Antiques

Masonstiques: Painted American Country Furniture & Folk Art

Austin T. Miller American Antiques, Inc.

Joshua Lowenfels

American Marine Model Gallery -- Fine Ship Models

Direct link to Joan R. Brownstein / American Folk Paintings

A.P.H. Waller & Sons Antiques, Select Antique Furnishings/Fine Art

Bernard & S. Dean Levy

Collectibles on Ruby Lane

AntiqueSpider.com

Antiques at Hillwood Farms

James D. Julia, Inc. Antiques & Fine Art Dept.

Search Online Auction Results

Pottery on Ruby Lane

Quiet Corner Antiques

Bob Smith Antiques

Tom & Rose Cheap-www.periodantiquesllc.com

Antiques at Pompey Hollow, Formal & Country Furniture, Rugs, Accessories & More

J.W. Grant Folk Art & Americana

Tex Johnson Antiques

A & A Gaines

Marna Anderson, Dealer and Broker in Americana, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Van Tassel ~ Baumann

Dan Freeburg Antiques

Dennis and Natalie Louwers

Direct link to House of the Ferret Antiques

Charles F. Breuel Antiques

New Hampshire Antiques Dealers Association

Peggy McClard Americana and Folk Art

Mark Reinfurt-Equinox Antiques & Fine Art

Axtell Antiques

Wiscasset, Maine, Antiques Dealers

Latcham House Antiques

Black Sheep Antique Center

Elaine's Antiques

Musée Secret

Home Farm Antiques

Nazmiyal.com-Fine Antique and Decorative Antique Oriental Rugs and Carpets

Direct link to Primarily Primitives

Michael and Lucinda Seward

Direct link to Dennis Raleigh Antiques

Hillsdale Barn Antiques

American Garage

Ken, Ida, & Kate Manko American Folk Art

Joan Lucas Antiques

Michiana Antique Mall

Otto and Susan Hart

Cadent Antiques-Charles & Victoria Dahlke

Silver on Ruby Lane


Greenwich Hardware Antiques

Hanes & Ruskin Antiques

Antiques & Collectibles on Ruby Lane!

Frank & Barbara Pollack

Early American Stoneware Warren F. Hartmann

Cabin Fever Gallery, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Direct link to burlsnuf.com/S. Scott Powers Antiques

Manko American Folk Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Direct link to Helen Warren Spector Antiques

Raccoon Creek Antiques, L.L.C.

Latique, America’s Premier Antique Resource, Antiques Trade Directory Advertisement

RJG Antiques

Olde Hope Antiques, Inc.

Gurley Antiques Gallery

Austin T. Miller American Antiques, Inc., Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Login | Forums | Trade Directory Search
Prices Database | Search Stories
Price of the Day | Subscribe
Maine Antique Digest
 Free Sample | Ad Rates
FTP Ads | Catalogs | Search Archives
Home

When Does Collecting Stop and Dealing Begin?

by David Hewett

Collector Richard Hopp of Van Nuys, California, is battling the city of Los Angeles and its police department over their definitions of "dealers." In November 2008 Hopp filed suit in Los Angeles Superior Court against the city and sought "Declaratory Relief to Determine Validity of Ordinances and Injunction."

Richard Hopp is a bail bondsman by profession and "an avid collector of books, documents, and ephemera as a hobby," to quote from his suit. Hopp stated that he sets up at "exhibitions, festivals, meetings, flea markets, swap meets, trade shows, garage sales, and collector meetings" and wishes to have an "exhibitor table" or "buying booth" at the events listed above. He claims that he's just a collector, though, and not a dealer or seller.

The city of Los Angeles has two ordinances relating to the regulation of secondhand book dealers and secondhand dealers in general. Those ordinances are enforced by the police department. That department has decided that Richard Hopp is "a secondhand book dealer" and must comply with the city's rules regulating those individuals.

As Hopp described his activities in a telephone interview, "I buy goods. Like a guy might set up a table with a sign 'I buy baseball cards,' I do it with books. I don't sell anything. I donate it or send it to the recycling bin."

"Actually, according to the municipal code," Hopp pointed out, "if I buy from anyone, I'm supposed to get their thumbprint and ID. If I'm buying on eBay, and they're located in California, I'm supposed to get their thumbprint and ID."

He gave those examples as an indication of how loosely authorities have enforced the various codes regulating the trade.

"I submitted about fifty public record requests trying to pin them [whoever polices the various legal codes] down. Every time, I get a response from the chief of police, or whoever, that I'm unintelligible. They don't understand what I'm saying, or say 'Go speak to a lawyer,' because they have it in their municipal code that if you buy, sell, or trade, you are a business."

In that light, the city of Los Angeles insists that Hopp needs a secondhand book dealer's permit, although he insists that he isn't a dealer. As proof of such, he alleges that he has obtained a statement from the California Department of Justice that preempts local ordinances.

The letter from the Department of Justice does reiterate that local law enforcement agencies, not the Department of Justice, are the licensing authority in California, but also notes that, from Hopp's own description of his activities (his statement that he does not "resell" his purchases), "it does not appear that your activities constitute a Secondhand Dealership."

A tax compliance officer with the custodian of records for the city of Los Angeles, responding to a request from Hopp for a "written exemption" from the need to apply for or obtain a business license, stated that they are unable to provide such to Hopp. The compliance officer, however, also noted that if, as he stated in his letter to them, he is "not engaged in business," then a certificate would not be required for his collecting activities.

The city remains adamant that Hopp has to apply for and get a permit, or license, to engage in his collecting endeavors in public.

In his lawsuit, Hopp asks the court to issue a permanent injunction restraining the city of Los Angeles from stopping him from "actively promoting, publicizing, and advertising his collecting and hobby activities…at exhibitions, festivals, meetings, flea markets, swap meets, trade shows, garage sales, and collector meetings within the jurisdiction of the City of Los Angeles."

We caught up with Richard Hopp on a hectic Monday, when he was in and out of a courtroom with tasks connected with his bail bondsman job. He told us that there had been no further developments in his suit against the city but noted that, "constitutionally, I'm supposed to go in front of anybody else. I'm not claiming damages. I'm asking for a constitutional determination, and that trumps all the other types of legal actions."

He cheerfully admitted that he is and has been a burr under the saddle of officials when he sees injustice being done. In 2003 and '04 it was the city of Maywood he faced down. Hopp had made a request for documents from city attorney David Olivas in late 2003 and got no response. At the city council meeting on November 25, 2003, Hopp reiterated his claims concerning fees charged by the city to people who had been arrested but not yet found guilty, fees that he said were illegal. On page four of those city council minutes for that date, the following is noted: "City Attorney David Olivas interjected that Richard Hopp was outside the City Hall yelling and interrupting the City Council's meeting." Olivas wanted an incident report written by the chief of police about the event. There is no record of any action taken by the city relating to that episode.

"I'm a Republican conservative," Hopp said, "but I don't let anybody in the world own the Constitution, and I don't let any government get down my pants, and if they do than I'm the guy who will show up at three o'clock in the morning and say '&#%* you, you've got to get out of my life!'"

One California municipality found out the hard way that it costs money to ignore his demands. In 2005 Hopp sued the city of Glendale for ignoring a request for information. Hopp and his attorneys were awarded $16,892.30, plus interest, by a state court.


Originally published in the January 2009 issue of Maine Antique Digest.
© 2008 Maine Antique Digest



Login or Register to post a Comment

Shows & Auctions
Click Here for Complete Show & Auction Calendar
(Show) Marburger Farm Antique Show (Round Top, TX)
(Auction) Auction Productions (Dewey-Humboldt, AZ)
(Show) Chicago Antique Market (Chicago, IL)
(Auction) Willis Henry Auctions Inc. (Marshfield, MA)
(Auction) Cowan's Auctions, Inc. (Cincinnati, OH)
(Show) Marburger Farm Antique Show, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Round Top, TX)
(Auction) Pook & Pook Inc., Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Downingtown, PA)
(Auction) James D. Julia, Inc., Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Fairfield, ME)
(Auction) Freeman's Auctioneer & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Philadelphia, PA)
(Auction) SeeAuctions.com (Live On-Line Auctons)
(Auction) John Moran Antique & Fine Art Auctioneers (Pasadena, CA)
(Show) J & J Promotions 2010 Antiques & Collectibles Shows, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Brimfield, MA)
(Auction) Early American History Auctions (Online-Absentee)
(Auction) James D. Julia, Inc., Antiques & Fine Art Division (Fairfield, ME)
(Auction) Garth's Auction Gallery (Pensacola, FL)
(Show) Brian Lebel's Old West Show & Auction, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Denver, CO)
(Show) Round Top Rifle Hall-Ralph Willard (Round Top, TX)
(Show) Whitehawk Antique Shows 2010, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Santa Fe, NM)
(Show) The Original Round Top Antiques Fair (Round Top, TX)
(Auction) Skinner Auctioneers & Appraisers of Antiques & Fine Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisem (Boston & Marlborough, MA)
(Auction) Rock Island Auction Company, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Moline, IL)
(Auction) Garth's Auctioneers & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Delaware, OH)
(Auction) MV Auctions (Hyannis, MA)
(Auction) Heritage Auction Galleries, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Dallas, TX)
(Auction) Clarke Auction Gallery (Larchmont, NY)
(Auction) AuctionZip.com (Find Auctions Anywhere)
(Auction) J.C. Devine Inc., Auctioneers & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Milford, NH)
(Auction) Roan Inc., Auctioneers & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Cogan Station, PA)
(Auction) Decoys Unlimited, Inc. ~ Theodore S. Harmon, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (West Barnstable, MA)
(Auction) Tim Potter Auction Services (Odessa, Ontario, Canada)
(Auction) Garth's (Delaware, OH)
(Show) The Philadelphia Antiques Show, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Philadelphia, PA)
(Auction) Rafael Osona
(Auction) Swann Galleries (New York, NY)
Feb 11, Feb 23, Feb 25
(Auction) Robert L. Foster Estates Auction (Newcastle, ME)
Feb 13
(Auction) Skinner Discovery Auction (Marlborough, MA)
Feb 17, Feb 18
(Auction) Litchfield County Auctions: Antiques Auction Including La Quercia House Collection and Stein Auction (Litchfield, CT)
Feb 17
(Show) 9th Annual Madison Antiques Show & Sale (Madison, GA)
Feb 18 - 20
(Show) Allman Promotions LLC New York & Massachusetts Antiques Shows (throughout NY & MA)
Feb 20, Feb 21, Mar 13, Mar 14, Jun 26, Jun 27, Jul 23, Jul 24, Jul 25, Nov 27, Nov 28
(Show) Winter in the Valley - Miller House Antiques (Fishersville, Virginia)
Feb 20
(Show) Renningers Antiques & Collectors Extravaganza (Kutztown, PA)
Feb 27, Feb 28
(Show) Renningers Mid Winter Classic Indoor Antiques & Collectors Show (King of Prussia, PA)
Feb 27, Feb 28
(Show) The Toronto Vintage Clothing and Textile Show (Toronto, Ontario, Canada)
Mar 6, Sep 25
(Auction) Northeast Auctions English & Continental Auction and Afternoon Estates Auction (Portsmouth, NH & Dover, NH)
Mar 13, Mar 18
(Show) Heart of the Valley Antiques Show (Bethlehem, PA)
Mar 13, Mar 14
(Auction) Northeast Auctions Important Americana Auction (Portsmouth, NH)
Mar 28
(Show) The Original Round Top Antiques Fair 42nd Annual Spring Antiques Fair (Round Top, TX)
Mar 31 - Apr 3
Where To Buy | Links | Contact Us | Find an Appraiser

© 2007 Maine Antique Digest

Web Hosting Provided by Maine Hosting Solutions