Maine Antique Digest
Maine Antique Digest
Gallery Advertisers

Search Our Advertisers

View Advertisers Alphabetically


De Wolfe & Wood Rare Books

Joan Lucas Antiques

Late-Breaking News on Auctions, Art, and Antiques

Frank & Barbara Pollack - American Antiques & Art

One Good Eye

McClellan Elms Antiques

Direct link to Antique Associates at West Townsend

Douglas Hamel Antiques www.shakerantiques.com

Susan Heider Antiques

Joshua Lowenfels, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Classified Ads

Showcase Antique Center

DBR Antiques, Americana - Folk Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

RJG Antiques

Direct link to Nancy Steinbock Vintage Posters

John Chaski Antiques

Just Folk American Antique and Outsider Art

Dig Antiques

Brian Murphy Antiques & Art

Silver on Ruby Lane

American Marine Model Gallery -- Ship Model Restorations & Appraisals

Austin T. Miller

Direct link to Dennis Raleigh Antiques

The Stanley Weiss Collection

Susan's Americana Gallery

Charles L. Flint Antiques, Inc.

Direct link to Primarily Primitives

Prices 4 Antiques

James D. Julia, Inc. Antiques & Fine Art Dept.

Regeantiques.com

Robert J. Riesberg - Fine 17th, 18th, and Early 19th Century Antiques

Halliday House Antiques

Blue Dog Antiques

The Manhattan Art & Antiques Center

Bob Smith Antiques

M. Finkel & Daughter, Antique Sampler Web Site

Fred Giampietro Folk Art and Americana

Now Casting For Life-Changing New TV Show

Charles Haver Antiques

Direct link to American Primitive Gallery

Direct Link to J. Compton Gallery

Peggy McClard Americana & Folk Art

Antiques at Hillwood Farms

Vintage Clothing on Ruby Lane

Wiscasset, Maine, Antiques Dealers

UNCERTAIN TIMES DEMAND SMARTER MARKETING

Patriot Antique Shoppe

American Marine Model Gallery -- Fine Ship Models

Antiques Dealers' Association of America, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Antiques & Collectibles on Ruby Lane!

Latcham House Antiques

burlsnuff.com / Steven S. Powers

Early American Stoneware Warren F. Hartmann

Latique, America’s Premier Antique Resource, Antiques Trade Directory Advertisement

Kaller Historical Documents, Inc.

Look What I Found

The Antique Store in Wayne, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

MacKay and Field Antiques: Next Update, Tuesday, August 31st, 8 P.M.

The Sportsman's Eye, Decoys & Sporting Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

David A. Schorsch & Eileen M. Smiles

Austin T. Miller American Antiques, Inc., Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Get M.A.D. in Print!

Mark Reinfurt-Equinox Antiques & Fine Art

Patricia Stauble Antiques, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Samuel Herrup Antiques

Heart of Country Antiques Show

Keepers Antiques

Jewelry on Ruby Lane

Gentle Giant Restoration & Conservation

Charles F. Breuel Antiques

Tom & Rose Cheap-www.periodantiquesllc.com

Thomas R. Field Antiques

Merry Walk Antiques ~ Joan Datesman, The Quimper Specialist, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Hanes & Ruskin Antiques

Gurley Antiques Gallery

Quaboag Valley Antique Center

Jane F. Wargo-Country Painted Furniture, baskets, trade signs, hooked rugs

Fine Art on Ruby Lane

Marna Anderson, Dealer and Broker in Americana, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Macdougall-Gionet

Bernard & S. Dean Levy

Jeff & Holly Noordsy

Leonards New England Antique Beds & Fine Antique Furniture Our Specialty Since 1933!

Scott Bassoff & Sandy Jacobs

Postcards on Ruby Lane

Barbara Ardizone Antiques

Porcelain on Ruby Lane

Masonstiques: Painted American Country Furniture & Folk Art

Woodbury Antiques Dealers Association

Claude and Sharon Baker Antiques

Greenwich Hardware Antiques

Quiet Corner Antiques

Wanted: Experienced Cataloger

Austin T. Miller American Antiques

Direct link to Helen Warren Spector Antiques

Halsey Munson Americana

Direct link to John R. Snedden Ltd.

Michael Hall Antiques, Southern Decorative Arts. "Cherry Sugar Chest ca. 1825-35."

Charles Wilson, Antiques & Folk Art

Vicky Daniel - Antiques at Creekside Farm

Raccoon Creek Antiques, L.L.C.

D L Straight Antiques Auctions

Sasha's Antiques

Get All of M.A.D.

Direct link to Lynn and Rob Morin Antiques, Americana and Folk Art

Books on Ruby Lane

Home Farm Antiques, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Down Home Antiques

The Barometer Shop ~ C. Neville Lewis, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Home Farm Antiques

Sniktaw Antiques LLC

Country Treasures -- American Country Antiques

Hanauer & Seidman Antiques

Michiana Antique Mall

Crocker Farm Stoneware & Redware Auction

Ruby Plaza-Home Decor & Jewelry powered by Ruby Lane

Hillsdale Barn Antiques

Linda Rosen Antiques

John Keith Russell Antiques

A.P.H. Waller & Sons Antiques, Select Antique Furnishings/Fine Art

North Carolina Museum of History: Behind the Veneer, Thomas Day, Master Cabinetmaker

Nazmiyal.com-Fine Antique and Decorative Antique Oriental Rugs and Carpets

Ken, Ida, & Kate Manko American Folk Art

Direct link to Jenkinstown Antiques

Search Online Auction Results

view antiques: 18th-20th American color for the eclectic decor

Latique, The Antique Resource for Dealers

Walpoles

Marion Harris - We Strive for a Perfect Sense of Balance

Don Olson Fine American Antiques

George Subkoff Antiques

Robert Walin/Tucker Frey

Brian Cullity

William Vareika Fine Arts Ltd. The Newport Gallery of American Art

New Hampshire Antiques Dealers Association

Glass on Ruby Lane

Jewett-Berdan Antiques

David Nassar Antiques

Antiques At 30B

Direct link to Joan R. Brownstein / American Folk Paintings

Ryder Antiques-Americana and International Folk Art and Painted Furniture

Otto and Susan Hart

Elaine's Antiques

Get all of M.A.D. Every Month!

George Subkoff Antiques, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Direct link to Nevermore Antiques

Houston Antiques Dealers Association

Sharon Platt American Antiques - Period Decorative Arts for the Early American Home

Antiques on Ruby Lane

Cabin Fever Gallery, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

America's Pride Antiques

Jordan Antiques

Old South Antiques Ltd.

Gentle Giant, Restoration and Conservation, Antiques Trade Directory Advertisement

Newsom & Berdan Antiques

American Antiques Inc.

The Dongan Collection, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Bid at Online Auctions

Direct link to Southampton Antiques American Victorian Furniture

Griffiths Antiques

Read The Current Issue

Direct link to David Pool Antiques

Axtell Antiques

Marna Anderson

The Stanley Weiss Collection, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Frank Finney Folk Art

Direct link to Nantucket Country

USFolkArt.com - American Antiques

Antique Associates at West Townsend

Michael and Lucinda Seward

Adrian Morris Antiques

Direct link to House of the Ferret Antiques

Raven's Way Antiques

A & A Gaines

Manko American Folk Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Collectibles on Ruby Lane

Dennis and Natalie Louwers

Antique Center of Strabane

Have M.A.D. Delivered to Your Mailbox

Antiques by Design

Scott Landon Antiques & Old Canada Country Antiques

Direct link to Staneika Antiques

Prairie Peddler Antiques

Pottery on Ruby Lane

Cherry Brook Woodworks

Direct link to The Splendid Peasant Ltd,

South Street Antiques Litchfield, CT

Joshua Lowenfels

The Royal Scot, Inc.

John C. Hill Antique Indian Art

More M.A.D. - Month After Month

Direct link to John D. Wahl Antiques

Baker & Co. Antiques

Austin T. Miller American Antiques, Inc.

Northeast Auctions

Sow's Ear Antique Company

Dan Freeburg Antiques

Jeffrey Tillou Antiques

Direct Link to Peter H. Eaton Antiques

Stella Rubin

Bruce Rigsby Antiques

Fisher Heritage

Thurston Nichols American Antiques, LLC

Dolls on Ruby Lane

Oh. - A Felicitous Gathering of Curious Goods

Nutting House Antiques

Anne Frances Moore: Fine Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement

Olde Hope Antiques, Inc.

Carlson & Stevenson

American Garage

Login | Forums | Trade Directory Search
Prices Database | Search Stories
Price of the Day | Subscribe
Maine Antique Digest
 Free Sample | Ad Rates
FTP Ads | Catalogs | Search Archives
Directory Signup | Home | Digital Edition

Arbus Photos Suit Is Settled

The dust jacket of the paperback edition of Hubert's Freaks by Gregory Gibson. Available at bookstores for $14.95 and also directly from Harcourt, Inc., Harcourt Trade Publishers, (800) 543-1918, (www.harcourtbooks.com). Pictured is Estelline Pike, sword swallower. The image is a non-Arbus photo from the collection of Robert C. Langmuir.

by Jeanne Schinto

Bayo Ogunsanya, a collector and private dealer of African-Americana and other items, said that on February 17 his lawsuit against Robert C. "Bob" Langmuir of Pennsylvania reached an out-of-court settlement. Ogunsanya filed the suit in April 2008 in federal district court in Brooklyn, New York, where he lives. He did so after learning that photos he had sold to Langmuir for $3500 in 2003 were works by Diane Arbus. The Arbus material was part of a much larger group of photos, notebooks, pamphlets, handbills, and other ephemera that Ogunsanya had bought the previous year at a sale of unclaimed items from a Bronx storage facility.

Langmuir, a rare-book dealer, had planned to sell the photos in April 2008 at Phillips de Pury & Company in New York City. The estimates on the 27 lots ranged from $20,000/30,000 to $80,000/120,000 each. But the auction house canceled the sale the day before it was scheduled to take place.

"Private Sale Pending" was the reason stated for the cancellation on the auction house's Web site (www.phillipsdepury.com). The New York Times and other media reports speculated contrarily that the lawsuit had killed it, while others pointed out that Ogunsanya had filed it weeks earlier, so they questioned the timing. A more likely scenario, many observers now believe, is that results on Arbus photo sales at other auctions that week caused Phillips to rethink the size of Langmuir's guarantee. In any case, the photos remain unsold.

Arbus (1923-1971), chronicler of the freakish and strange, made the photos early in her career, from 1958 to 1963. The location was Hubert's Dime Museum and Flea Market, once a celebrated freak show on Manhattan's 42nd Street. The story of how Langmuir came to identify the photos as the work of Arbus is the subject of a book, Hubert's Freaks: The Rare-Book Dealer, the Times Square Talker, and the Lost Photos of Diane Arbus by Gregory Gibson.

Ogunsanya (pseudonymed "Okie" in Gibson's book) sold Langmuir the Hubert's archive, along with the Arbus photos, in two batches. In his view, the fact of the two sales was crucial to his lawsuit. It argued that although Langmuir may not have known in the first instance that the photos were by Arbus, he definitely did when making a deal on the second batch.

According to Ogunsanya, the suit dragged on for so many months because Langmuir's lawyers filed motions to dismiss that were denied. Ogunsanya also said he will get "a percentage of the gross sale" when it takes place. The settlement bars him from giving any further financial particulars.

Asked if he was satisfied by the terms, Ogunsanya said, "Yes, this is a success for me. It's a done deal. And it's time for me to move on." He added, "It was a case that [Langmuir] couldn't win, and he probably hurt himself by delaying the settling of it, because of the market. Hopefully, he will be selling them for as much as he can get and soon too. But the economy is what it is."

It's not known at this time if the photos will be sold by Phillips. In the months since the sale's cancellation, controlling interest in the auction house was bought by the Moscow-based Mercury Group.

In an author's note to the paperback edition of Hubert's Freaks, released on April 15, Gibson wrote, "Bayo's lawsuit and the disappearing auction were followed by more bad news. An enthusiastic producer who'd been trying to line up Philip Seymour Hoffman to play Bob in a movie version of Hubert's Freaks informed us, regretfully, that Phil simply did not have time to take the project on. Bob was philosophical. 'How can we expect Phil to want to play me when I don't even want to play me?'"

Langmuir, when asked for his own comment on his troubles, said, "It's very gracious of you, but I can't say anything, so there you are."


Originally published in the April 2009 issue of Maine Antique Digest. (c) 2009 Maine Antique Digest



Login or Register to post a Comment

Shows & Auctions
Click Here for Complete Show & Auction Calendar
(Auction) Heritage Auction Galleries, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Dallas, TX)
(Auction) Roan Inc., Auctioneers & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Cogan Station, PA)
(Show) Marburger Farm Antique Show (Round Top, TX)
(Auction) Garth's Auction Gallery (Pensacola, FL)
(Auction) Pook & Pook Inc., Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Downingtown, PA)
(Auction) AuctionZip.com (Find Auctions Anywhere)
(Auction) Garth's Auctioneers & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Delaware, OH)
(Show) Whitehawk Antique Shows 2010, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Santa Fe, NM)
(Auction) Early American History Auctions (Online-Absentee)
(Show) Marburger Farm Antique Show, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Round Top, TX)
(Show) Round Top Rifle Hall-Ralph Willard (Round Top, TX)
(Show) Brian Lebel's Old West Show & Auction, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Denver, CO)
(Auction) Cowan's Auctions, Inc. (Cincinnati, OH)
(Show) J & J Promotions 2010 Antiques & Collectibles Shows, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Brimfield, MA)
(Auction) Rafael Osona
(Auction) Decoys Unlimited, Inc. ~ Theodore S. Harmon, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (West Barnstable, MA)
(Show) The Philadelphia Antiques Show, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Philadelphia, PA)
(Auction) Garth's (Delaware, OH)
(Auction) Rock Island Auction Company, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Moline, IL)
(Auction) Tim Potter Auction Services (Odessa, Ontario, Canada)
(Auction) John Moran Antique & Fine Art Auctioneers (Pasadena, CA)
(Auction) Clarke Auction Gallery (Larchmont, NY)
(Auction) James D. Julia, Inc., Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Fairfield, ME)
(Auction) Skinner Auctioneers & Appraisers of Antiques & Fine Art, Antiques Trade Directory advertisem (Boston & Marlborough, MA)
(Auction) Freeman's Auctioneer & Appraisers, Antiques Trade Directory advertisement (Philadelphia, PA)
(Auction) Willis Henry Auctions Inc. (Marshfield, MA)
(Auction) Reata Pass Auction Productions (Dewey-Humboldt, AZ)
(Show) The Original Round Top Antiques Fair (Round Top, TX)
(Auction) James D. Julia, Inc., Antiques & Fine Art Division (Fairfield, ME)
(Auction) Cottone Antique Toy & Collectible Auction (Geneseo, NY)
Sep 3, Sep 4
(Show) The Original 155th Semi-Annual York Antiques Show & Sale (York, PA)
Sep 3 - 5
(Auction) Robert L. Foster Important Maine Two-Day Estates Auction (Newcastle, ME)
Sep 4, Sep 5
(Auction) Davies Auctions Outstanding Antique Auction (Lafayette, IN)
Sep 4
(Auction) William A. Smith Inc. 43rd Annual Labor Day (2-Day) Auction (Plainfield, NH)
Sep 5, Sep 6
(Auction) Kimball M. Sterling, Inc., Skoby's Restaurant Absolute Auction (Kingsport, TN)
Sep 6
(Auction) Augusta Auction Company Historic Textile & Fashion Auction (Sturbridge, MA)
Sep 8
(Auction) Pook & Pook Inc. Fall Auctions (Downingtown, PA)
Sep 9, Sep 10, Oct 1, Oct 2, Oct 30, Nov 19
(Auction) Wiederseim Associates, Inc. Antique Auction (Glenmoore, PA)
Sep 10, Sep 11
(Show) 14th Annual Delaware Coast Antiques Show & Sale (Rehoboth Beach, DE)
Sep 10, Sep 11, Sep 12
(Auction) Auctioneers Heigel & Schmidt On-Site Auction (Hudson, NY)
Sep 11
(Auction) Neal Auction Company Important Estates Auction (New Orleans, LA)
Sep 11, Sep 12
(Auction) CRN Annual Fall Auction (Cambridge, MA)
Sep 12
(Auction) J. Levine Auction & Appraisal Fine Art - Antiques - Jewelry & Collectibles (Scottsdale, AZ)
Sep 12
(Auction) Bonhams & Butterfields Fine European Furniture and Decorative Arts (Los Angeles, CA)
Sep 13
(Auction) Time & Again Auction Galleries Consignments Wanted (Linden, NJ)
Sep 14, Sep 16
(Auction) Skinner Fine Jewelry Auction (Boston, MA)
Sep 14
(Auction) Skinner Discovery Auction featuring Estate Jewelry, Silver, Musical Instruments & Royal Doulton (Marlborough, MA)
Sep 15, Sep 16
(Auction) Bonhams - Estate of Laura Speiser, New York (New York, NY)
Sep 16
(Auction) Swann Galleries (New York, NY)
Sep 16, Sep 21, Sep 30
(Auction) Bonhams - Property from a Coconut Grove Private Collection (New York, NY)
Sep 16
(Auction) Stefek Auctioneers & Appraisers Fine Art, Furniture & Decorative Arts Auction (Grosse Pointe Farms, MI)
Sep 16
(Show) 28th Annual Country Folk Art Festival Show & Sale (St. Charles, IL)
Sep 17, Sep 18, Sep 19
(Show) Houston Antiques Dealers Assoc. Fall Antiques Show & Sale (Houston, TX)
Sep 17 - 19
(Auction) Lyn Knight Auctions (Lenexa, KS)
Sep 18
(Auction) Bruce & Vicki Waasdorp's American Pottery Auction (mail and phone)
Sep 18
(Auction) The Provincetown Art Association And Museum Fall Consignment Auction (Provincetown, MA)
Sep 18
(Auction) Thomas Closser Antique & Estate Auction (Endwell, NY)
Sep 18
(Show) Ann Arbor Antiques Market (Ann Arbor, MI)
Sep 18 - 19
(Auction) J. Levine Native American & Western Americana Auction (Scottsdale, AZ)
Sep 19, Sep 26
(Auction) Robert L. Foster Estates Auction (Newcastle, ME)
Sep 19
(Show) Renningers Antiques & Collectibles Extravaganza (Kutztown, PA)
Sep 23 - 25
(Auction) Philip Weiss Auctions Three-Day September Auction Event (Oceanside, NY)
Sep 24, Sep 25, Sep 26
(Auction) Bertoia Auctions, Donald Kaufman, Part IV (Vineland, NJ)
Sep 24, Sep 25
(Show) Antiques at the Rifle Hall (Round Top, TX)
Sep 24 - 26
(Show) Minneapolis Institute of Arts Design & Antiques Fair (Minneapolis, MN)
Sep 24 - 26
(Auction) Philip Weiss Auctions presents Antiques & Fine Art (Oceanside, NY)
Sep 24 - 26
(Show) Chatham Historical Society Antiques Show and Sale for Cape Cod (Chatham, MA)
Sep 25, Sep 26
(Show) Sterling McCall Antiques Showcase & Event Center (Warrenton, TX)
Sep 25 - Oct 2
(Show) Pleasant Hill Antiques Show & Sale/ 31st Locust Grove Antiques Market (Harrodsburg, KY/ Louisville, KY)
Sep 26
(Show) Maine Antiques Show & Sale (Augusta, ME)
Sep 26
(Show) The Original Round Top Antiques Fair 43rd Annual Fall Antiques Show (Round Top, TX)
Sep 29, Sep 30, Oct 1, Oct 2
(Show) Avenue Shows Antiques & Art at the Armory (New York, NY)
Sep 30 - Oct 3
(Show) 17th Annual Okemo Antiques Show (Ludlow, VT)
Oct 2
(Show) 47th Shenandoah Antiques Expo (Fishersville, VA)
Oct 8, Oct 9, Oct 10
(Show) The Old Montreal Antiques Show (Montreal, Quebec, Canada)
Oct 15, Oct 16, Oct 17
(Show) Autumn Hartford Antiques Show (Hartford, CT)
Oct 30, Oct 31
(Show) Allman Promotions LLC New York & Massachusetts Antiques Shows (throughout NY & MA)
Nov 27, Nov 28
(Show) Pure and Simple Antique Show & Sale (Kokomo, IN)
May 7 2011
Where To Buy | Links | Contact Us | Find an Appraiser

© 2007 Maine Antique Digest

Web Hosting Provided by Maine Hosting Solutions